A secret community of Escape Room Enthusiasts


Why Escape Reviews Vary

Someone once posted they were shocked how people could have such vast differences of opinion with escape rooms. There are a number of reasons that plague reviewers of other mediums, for example, personal preference, but escape rooms are a different beast.

Three things about escape rooms makes it near impossible to give an accurate assessment:

  1. The Escape Room changes
  2. The Player changes
  3. You can only do the room once

The Escape Room Changes

Unlike a movie, a book, or even a video game, an escape room will change over time. If I were to read Lord of the Rings now, it will be the same a year from now (barring undiscovered edits and reprints…don’t get all pedantic on me).

This isn’t the case for an Escape Room.

  • Owners may tinker with the escape room to make a better experience. They may tighten up puzzles, improve flow, add or remove difficulty. The escape room is being designed iteratively in an attempt to improve gameplay.
  • Owners may do NOTHING to the escape room. Ravaged by players and entropy, the room will become a haven of worn locks, broken props, and tattered decor.
  • Until all rooms become automated, the staff can make a huge difference:
    • Reset errors can change the game
    • How they respond to hint requests can change the game (too vague, too direct, too slow)
    • Not relaying correct information at the beginning can change the game (how to open a lock, where they are allowed to search)

You could argue this is the same for a restaurant, where staff, decor and ingredients will change the experience. And you are right! However, I, as a player, can only experience your room for the first time once. This brings us to the next point…

The Player Changes

No matter how unbiased people claim to be, there will always be a vast difference between a player’s first experience and their current experience. Given the novelty of escape rooms, the first time a player encounters an escape room is a game changer. Black lights are amazing and stumbling around in the dark with a malfunctioning lantern is exhilarating.

The most common problem a reviewer will encounter is an ever sliding scale: you think you will never find a room that could be worse or better, but then you do. Now what do you do? Go back and alter your other reviews? Not a fun place to be.

The below can change your perception of an escape room:

  • Your experience gained from doing many escape rooms.
  • The number of escape rooms you have done in a day (When puzzle fatigue sets in, a simple puzzle can become a herculean, rage-inducing exercise in tedium).
  • The number of people you are with (the room flow can change significantly depending on players).
  • Who those people are (if your team is awesome, you will have an awesome time. If people are awful, you will have an awful time).
  • Whether you won or lost (People like to say this doesn’t matter, but I think it does. If you win a bad room, you are annoyed. If you lose a bad room, you want to punch things in the face).

Again, unlike a sports game, having an off day means you will do better in the next game. Not so in an escape room which can only be done once.

Both the Player and Escape Room Changes

I didn’t add this in the above list because it combines the two and is a bit hard to define and place:

  • You may not see all of the room because other players worked on a puzzle.
  • The industry changes. Escape rooms may branch to focus on different things: set, decor, immersion, etc. However, as the industry advances, the tech will become dated and noticeable.

You Can Only Do a Room Once

This was brought up a number of times throughout the article: a room owner has one chance to impress the customer. If the room was broken somehow, a player can’t redo and experience it the way it was meant to be.

Honestly, my hat goes off to both escape room owners and reviewers! Owners are under a lot of pressure to get it right all the time, and reviewers have to assess a room knowing the above biases are in place.

This is why I’m glad I’m no longer a reviewer. Hah! However, that didn’t stop from one of my reviews being reviewed by Escape Room Review Reviewer. Check it out! 😀


  1. I generally agree. Although I think that there’s just as much variation in movie (and other media) reviews.

    People have different tastes, and that’s a good thing. This is yet another reason why Lisa and I write a detailed “Should I play?” section as opposed to giving a score. We want to give our readers a sense of what they should expect and let them decide if the room is or isn’t for them.

  2. [Ok sorry this is a bit techi but hey we’re talking about Escape Rooms…]

    Totally agree Errol. It’s two factor analysis where one axis the ‘intrinsic quality’ of the room VS the second axis which is the three variables you mentioned. Some rooms are better than others.

    I’ve found the biggest variable is the person’s own expectations. For example, one person might naturally see all the best things but someone else is actively seeking out the problems.

    Great idea for a discussion mate

  3. Great article. This is a frequent topic of discussion between me and the rest of my usual crew. We’ve had several occurrences in the past when we would go and try an escape room that was highly recommended by other Escapists but which would not convince us in the slightest, for the same reasons as explained in this article.

    This also depends on people’s focus and interests towards escape rooms. Someone looking primarily for immersion will love Amsterdam Catacombs and dislike The Secret Lab in Locked In Edinburgh while someone mostly interested in puzzles might feel the complete opposite.

    As the article mentions, there is also that “beginner’s eyes” versus “experienced Escapists vision”. I believe this is clearly visible on websites like TripAdvisor where there is a lot of reviews from first timers swallowing the reviews of real enthusiasts, giving a complete different feedback of their escapes. That was one of the reasons behind the creation of http://www.escape-aide.com and also how important the Top Escape Rooms Project is for Escapists searching for optimal trustworthy recommendations. 🙂

Leave a Reply